Reviews-Page
Blog
Can engaging our Children in learning music increase academic and career success, social emotional wellbeing, wealth, and physical health.
Saturday, 28 September, 2024 09:44

Effects of Music Training on Inhibitory Control and Associated Neural Networks in School-Aged Children: A Longitudinal Study (2019)

Inhibitory control, the ability to suppress an immediate dominant response, has been shown to predict academic and career success, social emotional wellbeing, wealth, and physical health. Learning to play a musical instrument engages various sensorimotor processes and draws on cognitive capacities including inhibition and task switching. While music training has been shown to benefit cognitive and language skills.

This passage explores inhibitory control, a key component of executive function tied to the brain’s prefrontal cortex. Inhibitory control helps suppress automatic responses, improving focus and decision-making, which is linked to areas such as the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, anterior cingulate cortex, and inferior frontal gyrus. Studies show that strong inhibitory control correlates with academic and career success, better social emotional health, and lower risks of substance abuse and physical health issues.

The passage reviews how programs that enhance inhibitory control (like mindfulness, exercise, and music training) improve these skills, especially in children. Some research points to short-term exercise, martial arts, and classroom-based programs helping develop inhibitory control. More recently, music training has been examined for its role in improving this function.

However, studies on the effects of music training on inhibitory control have produced mixed results, both for adults and children. While some studies found that musicians showed improved reaction times in tasks that require inhibition, others did not find significant differences. Various factors may explain these inconsistent results, such as differing definitions of “musician” and the type of music training programs. The need for studies with more socio-economic and cultural diversity is also emphasized.

The current study aims to investigate the long-term effects of music training on inhibitory control in children, comparing those with music training to those involved in sports and those without any structured extracurricular activity. The study  hypothesised that music-trained children will show greater behavioural and neural improvements in inhibitory control than other groups.

This study investigated the impact of group-based music training on inhibitory skills in children from under-resourced communities, using a four-year longitudinal design. It compared children involved in music training with those in sports and a control group (no structured after-school program). Children’s inhibitory control was assessed using tasks like delayed gratification and the Flanker task, both inside and outside an MRI scanner.

Key findings include:

  1. Flanker Task: Music-trained children showed gradual improvement in inhibiting dominant responses, especially after 3-4 years. Though all groups improved, only the music group’s accuracy in incongruent trials reached significant levels, suggesting a unique effect of music training. Overall, all groups had similar accuracy by year four, though music participants started slightly lower at year two, suggesting they had more to gain.
  2. Delayed Gratification: Music-trained children were faster in learning to delay smaller immediate rewards for larger future ones, showing enhanced rational decision-making compared to the other groups. The sports and control groups also improved but did so at a slower rate.
  3. Neural Correlates: In the fMRI Stroop task, the music group displayed accelerated neural maturity in brain areas associated with cognitive control, particularly the right inferior frontal gyrus (IFG). This trend aligned with faster reaction times in musicians seen in other studies, though differences between groups diminished by year four.

This study suggests that music training promotes earlier development of inhibitory control, possibly due to parallels with musical practice (example: error monitoring and attention to detail). Interestingly the correlation with the high percentage of bilingual children in the study,  suggests that both music training and bilingualism independently contribute to enhanced inhibitory skills.

A limitation was the decrease in sample size over the four years, and the study wasn’t randomised, so pre-existing differences between groups might have influenced the results. Despite this, the study offers evidence of music training’s modest but positive effects on inhibitory control in children from underserved communities.

https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/neuroscience/articles/10.3389/fnins.2019.01080/full

 

 
The Music Miracle: The Scientific Secret to Unlocking Your Child’s Full Potential. Moosicology Founder Liisa’s Book Out Now
Saturday, 03 February, 2024 12:13
 The Music Miracle: The Scientific Secret to Unlocking Your Child’s Full Potential.
Moosicology
Written by Moosicology Founder Liisa Henriksson-Macaulay, the book brings the science of music from the academic communities to the family households, answering many burning questions, such as:

*What makes my child more intelligent?

*Why are some children more successful at school than others?

*How can I help my baby develop?

*How can I temper those temper tantrums?

*How can I help my child make the most of their immense potential, when there are so many possible activities, yet so little time?

Click here to buy The Music Miracle today on Amazon.

“Never before have I seen such a comprehensive and in-depth review of the 
neuroscientific and psychological basis of the effects of music on young 
children. Parents and many others will be anxious to read it because of its 
very important message. Liisa Henriksson-Macaulay has blazed an important and 
pioneering trail for others to follow, and I wish this book every success.” 

Professor of Education, Psychologist FBPsS David J. Hargreaves, University of Roehampton 

“I am pleased to commend this is a very positive contribution to the public awareness of the power of music to transform children’s lives. Every child is musical. By encouraging their children to make the most of their innate musical potential, parents can support much wider cognitive, emotional and social development as their children grow. Liisa Henriksson-Macaulay’s narrative is engaging and full of rich personal anecdote, as well as a synthesis of key research findings and useful examples for parents of how music can be used successfully to nurture and strengthen children’s development.” 

Professor Graham Welch, Institute of Education, University of London 

“Henriksson-Macaulay’s book bursts with enthusiasm and a fantastic array of knowledge and suggested approaches for fostering the musical development of children. Her commitment to this cause never flounders. I applaud her.” 

Lucy Green, Professor of Music Education, University of London

 
The Benefits of Early years music engagement
Saturday, 18 November, 2023 10:43

There is a growing body of research suggesting that exposure to music in the early years can have positive effects on brain development in various ways. Here are some key findings from scientific studies:

  1. Cognitive Development:
    • Memory and Attention: Engaging with music can enhance memory and attention skills in children. For example, learning and remembering songs or musical patterns involve cognitive processes that can transfer to other areas of memory and attention.
    • Pattern Recognition: Musical activities often involve recognizing patterns, which can contribute to the development of early mathematical and logical thinking.
  2. Language Development:
    • Phonological Skills: Exposure to music, especially through singing and rhythmic activities, can contribute to the development of phonological awareness—the ability to recognize and manipulate sounds in language. This is a crucial skill for early language development.
    • Vocabulary Building: Songs often introduce new vocabulary and help children learn the sounds and meanings of words.
  3. Social and Emotional Development:
    • Social Bonding: Music activities, such as group singing or playing instruments, can foster social bonding and cooperation among children. These interactions contribute to the development of social skills.
    • Emotional Expression: Music provides a means for children to express and regulate their emotions. Singing, dancing, and playing instruments can be outlets for emotional expression and creativity.
  4. Motor Skills:
    • Gross and Fine Motor Skills: Activities involving movement to music, such as dancing or playing instruments, can enhance both gross and fine motor skills in young children. This can contribute to overall physical development.
  5. Neurological Benefits:
    • Brain Plasticity: Exposure to music has been linked to changes in brain structure and function. Musical experiences may enhance neural plasticity—the brain’s ability to adapt and reorganize itself in response to new stimuli and experiences.
    • Auditory Processing: Musical training may positively impact auditory processing skills, including the ability to differentiate between different sounds and tones.
  6. Executive Functions:
    • Executive Function Skills: Musical activities often require planning, organizing, and executing sequences of actions. Engaging in such activities can contribute to the development of executive function skills, including working memory and cognitive flexibility.
  7. Emphasis on Early Childhood:
    • Many studies emphasize the importance of introducing music at an early age when the brain is particularly sensitive to environmental stimuli and experiences.

It’s important to note that the benefits of early years music are often intertwined with the quality and nature of the musical experiences provided. Positive, engaging, and interactive musical activities tend to yield more significant developmental benefits. Additionally, individual responses to music can vary, and not all children may respond in the same way.

Parents, caregivers, and educators can play a crucial role in promoting positive musical experiences for children by incorporating music into daily routines, providing access to a variety of musical genres, and encouraging active participation in musical activities.

 
Children’s brain development and music: a winning combination featured in today’s Telegraph
Sunday, 01 January, 2023 08:08

There’s a  insightful and  comprehensive article that our founder was  interviewed in by the Telegraph titled ‘Can music make your child cleverer?’

The article discusses our founders book “The Music Miracle – the scientific secret to unlocking your child’s full potential” and studies on music and children’s brain development. The article also features some tips (on how to engage musically with your child) from The Grown-Up’s Guide of the Moosicology Package.

Still, I genuinely think it’s a fabulous read, as the writer has done a great bit of research to make one fact-packed and nicely written article! Furthermore, the benefits of music for children clearly need this kind of national exposure: us parents need to be more informed on how crucial music is for babies and children. I very nearly missed this opportunity myself with my son six years ago – not wanting to be a ‘pushy parent’, or ‘living my music dreams through my son’, I hesitated in introducing my peculiar obsession with music to him – so it was just as well I came across one study when he was just a few months old (in the wonderful parenting book What Every Parent Needs to Know by Margot Sunderland) – and when I started to look for more information, a whole new world opened up in scientific journals; a wealth of information on how music benefits the brain development of children.

Without further ado, here’s a snippet of the article, which you can read in full at The Telegraph site:

“Liisa Henriksson-Macaulay, 30, Finnish author of The Music Miracle, believes that she has found the key to enhancing a child’s development. “In Finland, most children go to a music playschool until the age of seven,” she says. “They teach the children music in a very child-centred way. The benefits of this are so amazing that when I moved to Britain, I wanted to bring them to British children.”

According to the PISA international league tables, Finnish children are 14 places above Britain in maths, sixth in the world in reading, and fifth in science. The country has become something of a cause celebre among educational experts, who have long searched for the secret of this success.

Henriksson-Macaulay’s six-year-old son, Toivo, has been having piano lessons since he was four. She also has music sessions with him for half-an-hour a week, and for Christmas she gave him a drum kit. “He is exposed to music of all different types,” she says.

In her book, she concludes that musical practice can produce nothing short of a “a full-scale brain upgrade”. She has also developed a system of music tuition called Moosicology, which is intended to be used by parents to maximise the benefits to their child’s development.

According to a collation of peer-reviewed studies quoted in the book, benefits of early engagement with music include improved performance in mathematics and languages; higher levels of IQ; better emotional fluency; greater self-esteem; a more powerful memory; and physical health and fitness.

Such elaborate claims might sound far-fetched, especially as they are made by a non-scientist. But the book has been verified by a number of leading academics at the Institute of Education and elsewhere.

For babies up to the age of one, Henriksson-Macaulay says, it is best to play them a range of music, including major and minor keys, and different time signatures, rhythms and scales. “In Britain, children’s songs are usually in 4/4 time, and in the major key,” she explains. “That’s a bit like speaking to kids only in verbs. For the full benefits, children need a variety of music.”

She suggests singing and clapping games for children under the age of four, and for those aged between five and seven, she recommends introducing instruments.

“The most dramatic benefits happen before the age of seven or eight,” she says. “But it is important not to create a hothouse environment, or there will be a connection between music and stress.” ”

 

Click here to read the full article – including what Alex James from Blur and Susan Hallam from the Institute of Education have to say about the meaning of music for child development!

 
Why Motor Skills Matter – And How to Boost Them In Your Child
Friday, 18 January, 2013 12:11

Have you heard the news? This week, the Telegraph reported:

“Rising numbers of pupils can “hardly move” at the age of 11 because of a lack of specialist PE teachers in primary schools, it was claimed.

Baroness Campbell said there was a danger that the Olympic legacy may be wasted as schools fail to convert a wave of goodwill towards sport into actual participation.

She warned that primary teachers received little formal training in PE and often lacked the confidence to deliver high-quality lessons in the subject.”

This is precisely the same problem that has been identified when it comes to music education. The majority of the teachers themselves do not have a background in music, so how are they supposed to teach it to our children? They don’t. I know a child who at school has learned to be proficient at recognizing the sound of different instruments, but doesn’t know how to tell major from minor, let alone count beats or read music.

The problem with this is what Lamb and Gregory identified back in 1993: learning to recognize sounds of instruments, timbres, does not boost the brain. Only music training does. Lamb and Gregory’s finding was that the better your child is at recognizing pitches, the better their reading skills are. And by boosting these melodic skills by ear training, their reading skills improve.

But what’s more relevant for today’s topic, music training also boosts motor skills. This belongs in what Howard Gardner has called ‘bodily-kinesthetic intelligence’. Back in the 1960s, scientists found that when people train while music plays in the background, they are able to lift significantly more weights and run faster and longer than they did without music. (This explains why the Body Pump class blasts louder dance music than your average nightclub.)

A crucial discovery was made in 1967 by G. L. Beisman who organized an experiment on over 600 children. The children were divided into two groups that were taught motor skills such as kicking, jumping and throwing with an identical amount of repetitions and identical instruction. The only difference was that the other group was taught this with rhythmic music, and the other group didn’t have music on at all. The children who were taught through music ended up learning these crucial motor skills significantly better than the children who were taught without music.

A more recent study from 2004 by Evridiki Zakhopoulou and her research group found that standard PE classes failed to improve the motor skills of children (aged 4-5 in this study) at all, whereas the music and movement groups had improved their motor skills and balance in just two months!

Brain imaging studies now have shown that music training activates the motor regions of the brain. In fact, even listening to rhythmic music activates the motor regions, making babies who listen to music with a beat (such as drums or percussion) spontaneously try and match their movements to music! (Zentner & Eerola, 2010) This is crucial for not only their motor development but their intellectual development, as bad rhythmic motor skills predict future learning difficulties (see, for instance, Waber, Weiler, Bellinger, Marcus, Forbes, Wypij & Wolff, Diminished motor timing control in children referred for diagnosis of learning problems, 2000) whereas good rhythmic motor skills, such as clapping and moving to rhythm, predict higher academic achievement in the years to come (see, for instance, Brodsky & Sulkin, 2011).

Don’t let your child fall behind — let your child shine with moving to music!

 
10 Christmas songs that train your child’s brain
Saturday, 24 November, 2012 12:11
CandleIt’s beginning to look a lot like that time of the year again. On the surface, Christmas may hold different meanings to different people, but behind the differences a few undisputed core values emerge: family and the loved ones. Gifts, Christmas cards and joint celebrations all promote love and togetherness. Most of all, Christmas is a time for children: after all, Christmas started from celebrating the birth of a child. 

Many of the most popular Christmas carols feature rhythm concepts that are otherwise not as commonly found in Western music. New research shows that there is not a better way to train a small child’s brain than to help them clap along to different rhythm concepts. Here’s just a few key findings of recent research:

– the better your child is at handclapping songs before starting school, the more they will succeed academically from the start (2011 study from Ben Gurion University in Israel, click here for link)

– whether your child is at school yet or not, once they engage in handclapping training, their memory, handwriting and motor coordination improves (as above, click here for link)

– children who learn different rhythm concepts succeed 50% better in maths tests than children who are taught the traditional pen-and-paper way. Learning through music helped improve especially those pupils’ maths skills who were previously low achieving in mathematics (2012 study from San Francisco University, click here for link)

You can easily encourage your child to clap along to the 3/4 time signature or dance along to the shuffle beat of popular Christmas music. It’s fun, so your child won’t even realize they’re training for academic success! A win-win for the whole family.

Most songs and compositions in the Western tradition, whether classical, popular or jazz, center around the 4/4 beat (ie it’s based on the repeated counting of one-two-three-four). 4/4 beat is the standard beat that most everyone, with or without music training, will have gotten accustomed to just by living in a Western country, whether England, United Stated, Finland or Australia. Music scholars such as Edwin E. Gordon have criticized this one-sided musical diet that is fed to most children. Children simply do not hear enough of alternative time signatures.

But Christmas songs make an exception. A wide range of popular Christmas carols have the 3/4 time signature, colloquially known as the ‘waltz beat’, where you count one-two-three, one-two-three… Thus, Christmas with its omnipresent carols are arguably the easiest way to introduce your child to the 3/4 time signature and teach them to clap its beat, if you haven’t done this already. 

The shuffle beat is also present in many Christmas songs — especially in the tradition of Christmas hit songs in popular music. The shuffle beat is where each individual beat (each one of the countings of ‘one’, two’ three’ in 3/4 time and ‘one’, two’, ‘three’ and ‘four’ in 4/4 time is a beat) divides into three instead of two.

Here’s 10 songs to teach your child these two different rhythm concepts. You can start with picking just one song from each list and clapping along with your child. It is that simple!

 

Five of the most popular Christmas songs in the 3/4 beat:

We Wish You a Merry Christmas

Silent night

O Christmas Tree

O Holy Night

Happy Christmas (War is Over) by John Lennon and Yoko Ono

 

Five popular Christmas songs in 4/4 shuffle time (note that this is not the typical 4/4 time but 4/4 shuffle):

Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer

Frosty the Snowman

It’s Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas

All I Want For Christmas Is You — recorded by Mariah Carey and others

Wonderful Christmastime by Paul McCartney

 

To ensure your child’s learning success after Christmas, why not let Santa bring them their own Moosicology Package. Moosicology features many songs in both 3/4 time and shuffle time, as well as stories, instructions, colourful pictures and charming characters that help your child grasp all these different rhythm concepts so crucial for making the most of your child’s inherent potential!

Let your child shine bright like a Christmas candle! Merry Christmas from the Moosicology family.

 


Written on 28 September, 2024 09:44 by Moosicology
Written on 03 February, 2024 12:13 by Liisa Henriksson-Macaulay
Written on 18 November, 2023 10:43 by Moosicology
Written on 18 January, 2013 12:11 by Liisa Henriksson-Macaulay